Search for the perfect stitch markers

April 15th, 2005

(This post is missing a few photos, but it’s getting old now, and I came down with the flu—no photos or knitting happening lately. Just bad daytime TV and stacks of empty Kleenex boxes)

I used to make a lot of jewelry, so I thought stitch markers would be a snap. The classic way to make them would be to use a jump rings (round circles of wire) with sufficient diameter to accommodate a needle, and add beads strung on a head pin (a straight stick of wire with a little stopper at the end to hold the beads) and wrap the remaining head pin wire around the jump ring to secure. Simple.

However, I didn’t have jump rings, and jewelry making at my house is a spontaneous business. Alternative #1 was to use a 2” head pin, short beads, and make the big loop out of the head pin wire. Easy! This works fine, and makes short, light little markers:

(imagine picture here of the stitch markers on unfinished Clapotis #1)

These first stitch markers were eaten by the Clapotis that I started last winter, a project I abandoned as soon as I started dropping stitches (I’m not sure I like the hand of the yarn in its final form—it seems too light). Anyway, there sat my entire bounty of markers, trapped by an unfinished project.

I tried again soon after. This time, I still had no jump rings, and I’d used up all head pins long enough to create the big loop. Alternative #2 was devised: create the entire marker with bead threaded on plain wire, and secure the bead with a little spiral. I just love the look:

Spiral stitch markers

These, however, failed the knit test. I made them for gifts, and fortunately started using a couple before mailing them off. Those pretty little spirals trap yarn, getting tangled and sometimes snagging stitches. This will.not.do. I’m honing in on some key criteria, however, with this failure.

Stitch marker requirements:

  • They must be light enough not to add noticeable weight to the needles.
  • They must be pretty, and make knitting feel like a special indulgence.
  • They absolutely should not harm the knitting in any way, or cause frustrating tangles

I bought some jump rings to try again. My preference was for the solid ones (called “closed” on most sites), but I couldn’t find ones that were big enough, so I picked up a cheap package of the open jump rings (there’s a little split in the circle). Maybe the splits wouldn’t snag anything? I started knitting away on Clapotis #2, this time just using just the jump rings as markers. We’ll say that I meant to do this as a test, not because I was too lazy to get the jewelry tools out.

See the little split in the circle?

Open jump rings - a failure as a stitch marker

I hate them. Invariably, those little splits find all the little sensitive spots on my hands, causing a scratch or a prick.

Add one more criterion:

  • Stitch markers should not hurt!

Last weekend I dragged the jewelry stuff out to try them again. In some old experiments, I found the solution for Alternative #3: use wire, and secure the beads by wrapping the wire through and then up and around the bead. As you tighten the wire, you can create little designs. They’re kinda random and artsy-fartsy—I’m pretty happy with them:

Blue wire-wrapped stitch markers

Amber wire-wrapped stitch markers

They still have to pass the knit test, though. I’m about to try them out as I start the decrease section of Clapotis #2. Wish me luck!

(imagine photo here of stitch markers on current, almost-finished Clapotis #2)

Filed under , by Sara at 10:09 am |

13 Responses to “Search for the perfect stitch markers”

  1. margene Says:

    That last bunch is so pretty that I hope they work!

  2. Nancy Says:

    I really love the final batch.
    They are so beautiful. Good luck with them.

  3. Kathy Says:

    I have to say your stitch markers are more fabulous than most jewelry! And you take fantastic photographs! Do you have any tips for taking such good pictures?

  4. Lauren Says:

    They’re so gorgeous and you took such great photos of them. I hope they’re a perfect fit for Clapotis.

  5. JenE Says:

    Wow, I hope they work as beautifully as they look.
    Beautiful. Finger candy, just like yarn.

  6. sequinK Says:

    Nice! I think the last ones will work well—no snarky ends for snagging.

    And if you decide you MUST have closed jump rings, I think Rio Grande has a good selection of sizes. Just add me to the list of lapsed wireworker/beaders!

  7. Madalyn Says:

    They’re fabulous! I especially like the blue ones.

  8. Nancy Says:

    Good progress to a great final product. I discovered some of the same “snags” myself working mine out. You’re a much better beader than I – those wrapped ones are “pro”. For future ref, I found sterling jump rings and pins made for the lightest findings.

  9. Miss Twiss Says:

    All of your markers are pretty, but the last ones are real knock-outs! Good job. Good criterion. Good product!

  10. Secret Pal Says:

    Yep. You found me! And by the way, these markers are absolutely gorgeous! Take care!

  11. jess Says:

    i ADORE these, esp. the blue ones with the wrapped wire! i have never taken any class or anything in jewelry making, and have a terrible time manipulating wire so that it doesn’t look jagged or mangled. do you have any advice or know of any resources on line for learning to use wire the way you have here?

  12. Sara* Says:

    Each post I read down I get more entranced! You are too artsy for words!

  13. lynette Says:

    your stitch markers are gorgeous i love the wire wraps.